Cyrus McCormick Inventor Of Reaper Commemortive Coin What's it Worth?

$2 ?

eBay....offered at buy it now from $8 to $40....didn't look at completeds, but you can (or could have). 

I'll always look stuff up on ebay just as a quick reference but I dont use ebay as a guide for value, especially for collectible stuff. Often times the price you'll get if you actually seek out collectors is completely different than ebay.

I was doing some research online and guys were saying $18 to $60 where as like you said on ebay I saw several for under 10 bucks. Mine isn't in the best shape though.